00:00
Charlie Rose: Larry Ellison for the hour, next. Larry Ellison is the founder and CEO of Oracle, he is the third-richest man in the United States on the Forbes list said to be worth $43 billion. He is also the sponsor and manager of Oracle Team USA, the American sailing team in the 2013 America's Cup competition. Next month in San Francisco Oracle Team USA will defend the trophy it won in 2010. Thanks to new rules Ellison pioneered this year's boats will be faster and more expensive than any craft in the race's 162-year-old history. Last week on assignment for CBS "This Morning" I spoke with Ellison at his home south of San Francisco. We talked about his team, his philosophy and his friendship with the late Steve Jobs. Here is that conversation. I ought to say as we begin, thank you for inviting us to this remarkable place that were sitting in.
01:08
Larry Ellison: Well welcome back, Charlie. It's great to see you again.
01:12
Charlie Rose: Someone said to me that -- I asked them to describe you and they said "Larry likes to win."
01:19
Larry Ellison: I think -- I do. I do like to win. Well, let me say I like to compete. And I like to discover my own limits. I like to test my own limits. Sometimes the kids are sailing I like to test the limits of technology. But I enjoy the competition. I enjoy, if you will, the fight. And if you enjoy the fight and you work hard in the fight you'll win a fair share of the fights.
01:50
Charlie Rose: So what does winning the America's Cup mean?
01:53
Larry Ellison: Well, I'm not going to answer that question because I remember long time ago I was asked is it worth a $100 million to win the America's Cup and I said I have no idea I've never won the America's Cup but it sure isn't worth $100 million to lose the America's Cup which I had done twice. And then in 2010 we built this amazing machine, this trimaran with the 23- story tall wing mast and we won the America's Cup. Team USA won the America's Cup for the first time. And it was the end of a very long quest that had become a bit of an obsession.
02:27
Charlie Rose: Why?
02:30
Larry Ellison: It's an interesting question. I thought I -- I thought that I could put a team together -- it's a combination of technology and athletes. It's the blending of great technology and great athletes and I thought I could do this as well as anybody. I've been very successful as a sailor myself. I've been very successful as an amateur sailor. I'm very successful as a professional sailor and the next step, the next natural step in the evolution of competition in sailing is the America's Cup.
03:00
Charlie Rose: So this is more than some very wealthy billionaire saying "I'm going to go out and buy the best boat and the best talent and then I'll win for myself and America's Cup?"
03:11
Larry Ellison: Well in the beginning the first America's Cup that we did in New Zealand I actually ended up driving the boat a lot of the time.
03:17
Charlie Rose: Yes.
03:19
Larry Ellison: And -- well, we lost. I shared -- I shared the driving with Peter Holmberg.
03:24
Charlie Rose: Yes.
03:27
Larry Ellison: And we weren't doing very well and I eventually pulled myself off the boat, I brought back, Peter did all the driving, we brought back Kostecki and to be a tactician, it's a long story. But we ended up losing in the final of the Louis Vuitton Cup, this team from Switzerland skippered by the world's greatest sailor, Russell Coutts. And I just should have known better. You know Russell Coutts always wins.
03:52
Charlie Rose: Yes. So you'll pull Larry Ellison off the boat if it means winning the America's Cup for Larry Ellison?
03:59
Larry Ellison: Absolutely. I mean I want to be part of a winning team and if it helps a team to win for me to get off the boat I want to get off the boat.
04:09
Charlie Rose: These new boats, is they're not without criticism. Why is it necessary? Some people say "It's not the America's Cup. We've gone too far."
04:22
Larry Ellison: People really criticized professional athletes going into the Olympics. People don't like change. There was the Corinthian spirit of athletics where professionals were really looked down upon, only amateurs were allowed to compete. Professional tennis players were banned from Wimbledon. A lot of people didn't like the new metal rackets --
04:43
Charlie Rose: Yes.
04:45
Larry Ellison: -- where you can hit the ball harder. A bunch of people don't like the Olympics now because we've added skateboarding and --
04:52
Charlie Rose: Well, this is different. This is not a modification; this is a dramatic change.
04:56
Larry Ellison: Well, I would say that snowboarding is a dramatic change --
05:02
Charlie Rose: Yes.
05:04
Larry Ellison: -- in addition to the Olympics. We're modernizing the sport. So it used to be -- I sailed a boat called "Sayonara".
05:10
Charlie Rose: Yes.
05:12
Larry Ellison: That I raced around the world that could have killed the America's Cup champion. The America's Cup wasn't racing -- they weren't racing the fastest boats.
05:20
Charlie Rose: Yes.
05:22
Larry Ellison: And we decided that the America's Cup to capture the imagination of the modern world and children who can watch all these other sports and participate in all of these other sports, we had to modernize it, we had to make it exciting, we had to make it extreme.
05:35
Charlie Rose: And is there a cost of that?
05:38
Larry Ellison: I don't -- well, I think some people who wistfully look back to the blue -- you know the blue blazers and the brass buttons and the cute little ties with the flags on it, they'll you know -- they'll miss the traditions of the America's Cup which goes back to 1851. It's the oldest trophy in sports.
05:55
Charlie Rose: So what do you say the new tradition of the America's Cup is?
06:01
Larry Ellison: Fastest boats, the best sailors. So we have the best professional sailors who are incredibly fit, big athletes driving these unbelievably fast boats to their limits. So it's the limit as to what technology allows in 21st century sailing.
06:17
Charlie Rose: Now let me go back to the original question. You have won the America's Cup. You don't need to win it twice.
06:24
Larry Ellison: No.
06:27
Charlie Rose: So what is it within Larry Ellison who said "Man, I've won it once, I want the fastest boat, the best sailors and I want to win it again and maybe again?"
06:36
Larry Ellison: Well -- it's funny, because I realized after losing the America's Cup twice I was just -- my personality didn't allow me to quit while I'm losing.
06:44
Charlie Rose: Yes.
06:46
Larry Ellison: And then after winning the America's Cup I discovered my personality doesn't want me to quit while I'm winning. So I'm kind of trapped. I just can't quit. I don't know. I guess other people have that trouble with cigarettes.
06:59
Charlie Rose: Yes.
07:02
Larry Ellison: I don't smoke but I do sail.
07:05
Charlie Rose: But if you win this time will that be enough?
07:07
Larry Ellison: Well, I think it's -- I think it's enough. I mean it's not a matter of personal satisfaction right now.
07:13
Charlie Rose: Yes.
07:15
Larry Ellison: It's just personal satisfaction, it's a matter of we represent our country, this is team USA.
07:19
Charlie Rose: Yes.
07:22
Larry Ellison: We're going to be competing, you know, for the America's -- defending the America's Cup in the United States and we have a bunch of guys who committed the last several years of their lives to designing these boats, building these boats, making these boats sail as fast as they possibly can and I certainly owe it to them to give it 100 percent effort, to do whatever I can to help the people win.
07:40
Charlie Rose: Why do you think San Francisco is such a great place for racing?
07:44
Larry Ellison: It's just so beautiful.
07:46
Charlie Rose: Is that -- it's the beauty rather than the winds?
07:50
Larry Ellison: Well we do have consistent winds. We do have wonderful --
07:54
Charlie Rose: Consistent.
07:56
Larry Ellison: We do have wonderful consistent winds. You can rely that 1:00 o'clock -- rely on the wind coming in about 1:00 o'clock every afternoon and getting good breeze and -- and actually having sailboat races. One of the problems with sailing and televising sailing -- by the way, this is the other thing. We've got to make the sports spectacular.
08:10
Charlie Rose: Exactly.
08:12
Larry Ellison: We've got to make it spectacular on TV because there are only so many people that can actually watch this race. Now more people will watch this America's Cup race than all of the America's Cup races in history because all the America's Cup races in history have been offshore. This one is in a harbor. So we have people from office buildings, in their homes from the shore watching the race as it goes on. So it's accessible. But even more important it's accessible on TV because it's now spectacular graphics that help non-sailors to understand what's going out on the water.
08:41
Charlie Rose: There is this: some people say you want to make it Nascar on water. And people go to Nascar to see the crashes. They do.
08:52
Larry Ellison: I'm going to get in trouble. I'm not a Nascar fan nor a Formula One fan. I think this is better. And -- and we don't want to see anybody get hurt. It is certainly true that when Russell Coutts flipped the AC45 a couple of years ago --
09:11
Charlie Rose: Yes.
09:13
Larry Ellison: -- no one would talk to us up until then. None of the networks would talk to us until there was this fabulous YouTube video of the AC45 flipping over and Russell Coutts our CEO and the world's most decorated sailor falling through the wing and fortunately he was not hurt. But all of a sudden all of the networks wanted to broadcast.
09:34
Charlie Rose: So you were saying once it became this fast with this boat it became dangerous and that made it more attractive?
09:40
Larry Ellison: I think we like the illusion of danger, not real danger.
09:46
Charlie Rose: It's not the illusion, though.
09:50
Larry Ellison: Well, these boats -- the 45s flip over a lot. In Portsmouth we had six or seven of them flip over and we really had nobody seriously hurt ever in the 45s. The accident that we had on the -- on the Swedish boat --
10:03
Charlie Rose: Yes.
10:06
Larry Ellison: -- was a freak accident. There was actually a structural failure on the boat. The -- you know the two hulls are held together by cross beams.
10:14
Charlie Rose: Yes.
10:16
Larry Ellison: And where the cross beam attached to the lowered hull, those bolts sheared and the boat went from a rectangular boat and to a triangular boat and Bart Simpson tragically -- the boat flipped over and Bart Simpson was actually trapped between the two hulls and we couldn't find him for seven minutes so we had divers in the water 30 seconds after that boat flipped over. We've taken you know lots of safety precautions.
10:34
Charlie Rose: Yes but I'm told the death of Simpson really had an impact on you.
10:39
Larry Ellison: Oh, yes. I mean it's a -- we decided to make this an extreme sport, to make it exciting. We certainly never intended anyone to be hurt. The sailing community is a very small community. It's a small world. There aren't that many people that do this. Like professional tennis, everybody knows everybody and when you lose one of your own, it's - - you know, it's something you never, ever forget.
11:05
Charlie Rose: Did you for a moment say "We've gone too far?"
11:09
Larry Ellison: I thought about it. I thought about it. But no, I think we've made the right decision. I think to make this sport an economically viable sport we have to have fast, modern boats. It has to be a popular TV sport. It has to be attractive to kids. It has to --
11:31
Charlie Rose: And it has to be risky?
11:33
Larry Ellison: It has to be a little -- look a bit risky. It has to be a little bit risky. This is extreme sailing and these are highly skilled professionals who are superb athletes. You know we had all the guys carry oxygen. All the guys you know --
11:46
Charlie Rose: Since Simpson's death?
11:49
Larry Ellison: They carried oxygen before Simpson's death. We carry knives. We wear helmets; we wear body armor so we can cut -- you know so we can cut ourselves free if we're trapped below. So we've taken and we think, every precaution, this was just absolutely a freak accident that caused the loss of Bart Simpson and none of us will ever forget it.
12:11
Charlie Rose: But I mean you have faced death before. I mean "Sayonara" that day, on that boat you thought -- you survived but there were moments in which you didn't think you were going to survive or not?
12:20
Larry Ellison: Well, I wouldn't say I didn't think I was going to survive. I certainly thought we might die and I was you know, I said "What a stupid way to die. I mean who in their right mind flies to Australia for a race on December 26th when their family is in the Caribbean on the beach?"
12:37
Charlie Rose: Yes.
12:39
Larry Ellison: I'm -- I'm on a sailboat sailing south.
12:41
Charlie Rose: In a storm.
12:43
Larry Ellison: In a hurricane and ended up spending two days in a hurricane.
12:48
Charlie Rose: What was that like?
12:50
Larry Ellison: Well, we had a couple of guys on the boat who -- who had been in Vietnam and they said -- one guy turned to me and said "You want to know what combat is like? This is what combat is like. Can you taste the adrenaline in your mouth? Do you notice you're not blinking? Do you notice you never get tired? Notice how everything slows down? You notice how if you're hurt you don't care or even notice?" It is -- you're going -- you're in an altered state. There is no fear. There's just this -- I wouldn't call it calmness. There's this intense focus on doing your job.
13:22
Charlie Rose: And how much did you like this?
13:25
Larry Ellison: I didn't like it at all. I didn't like it, I didn't dislike it. I didn't have any -- any -- there's no kind of affect -- all I did was -- when I was driving. When I was -- when I was on deck and when I was driving all I did was focus on my job. When I went below to try to rest and thought about it, me and my rationalist -- boy, this is a stupid way to spend your Christmas-New Year's holiday.
13:50
Charlie Rose: Yes.
13:53
Larry Ellison: It's sailing in a hurricane is not something I ever want to do again.
13:58
Charlie Rose: Why are there only four boats entered here?
14:00
Larry Ellison: I think a couple things. The boats are brand new. I mean in the America's Cup a lot of the teams are on strict budgets and what they do is buy used boats from the previous America's Cup campaign. So there was no inexpensive way to get into this America's Cup. So these -- these boats are more expensive than we realized when we designed the class rule, these 72-footers. They are pretty expensive to build and they are pretty expensive to transport around the world. The world economy -- you know when we started the America's Cup was really in the tank so the combination of these boats are, I think, too expensive and the fact that the world economy is just coming --
14:44
Charlie Rose: But does that do some damage to the sport? That it's gotten to the point where only a very few people can compete?
14:52
Larry Ellison: Well, I think we're going to look at it next time around and make sure that -- two things will be true next time around. One, there will be used boats on the market if we go back to 72s, or we might conduct the next America's Cup in 45-foot catamarans. Also very extreme foiling, flying you know flying catamarans. We think it would be a spectacular event in 45s and I think it's very, very important to have more countries participating. We want the Chinese. We want the Japanese. We want you know we certainly -- we want the French and the Germans. We want the Brits. We want the South Africans.
15:26
Charlie Rose: So what do you have to do to get them?
15:27
Larry Ellison: We have to control the budget. We have to make it economical -- economically --
15:31
Charlie Rose: So you can't buy your way to the America's Cup?
15:32
Larry Ellison: So there's no big economic barrier to keep other countries out right.
15:38
Charlie Rose: So should you change the size of the boat?
15:40
Larry Ellison: We're looking of going back to 45s.
15:42
Charlie Rose: Do you believe that's the way to go?
15:45
Larry Ellison: I'm leaning -- I'm certainly leaning that way and so is Russell Coutts.
15:49
Charlie Rose: And why are the both of you leaning that way?
15:52
Larry Ellison: Because we want more countries to participate and lower the economic barriers.
15:56
Charlie Rose: But is it safer or less safe?
15:58
Larry Ellison: Oh I think the 45s are considerably safer.
16:00
Charlie Rose: Exactly. So that may be a factor, too.
16:03
Larry Ellison: It's all factors. I mean we flip the 45s a lot.
16:06
Charlie Rose: Yes.
16:08
Larry Ellison: It's very exciting. Again the 45s I guess is truly the illusion of dangers and extreme sport that people aren't going to get killed on those things. The 72s it's a -- there's much more potential for someone being hurt.
16:21
Charlie Rose: What's the difference in running Oracle and running an America's Cup challenge?
16:25
Larry Ellison: I think they're kind of the same thing, different skill.
16:29
Charlie Rose: And the skills are the same?
16:31
Larry Ellison: The skills are the same. Hire great people and make sure you have to hire great engineers.
16:36
Charlie Rose: Yes.
16:38
Larry Ellison: Because the design of the boat can make -- can make all the difference. But these boats are not identical so you can get significant advantages in the race by designing a lighter faster boat, a foiling boat with more lift and less drag. So you've got to have great engineers, you've got to have great athletes; you've got to have great managers, leaders, great marketing. You have to design the boat and make it beautiful. In this case we had to -- I own the company that has done all of the technology for the TV broadcasts.
17:09
Charlie Rose: Greg Dalton back to racing said --
17:12
Larry Ellison: Yes.
17:14
Charlie Rose: -- this is yachting and it's not Formula One and with all of the will of Oracle, he said, it is not Nascar.
17:22
Larry Ellison: Well, i interesting that he said this is yachting not Formula One. I don't even know what that means. Yachting. What is yachting?
17:33
Charlie Rose: Now, what's your answer?
17:35
Larry Ellison: This is professional racing. We have sponsors, the sponsors want as many people to see these boats in action as possible. We're also trying, you know we're competing with other sports to get kids' attention and we want -- we've got to make our sport exciting and we've got to modernize it.
17:51
Charlie Rose: Yes.
17:54
Larry Ellison: And it can't -- it can't be unchanged since 1851.
17:59
Charlie Rose: What is it about Larry Ellison that made Oracle what it is?
18:06
Larry Ellison: I think the -- the thing that caused problems for me in school are the same things that help me succeed in the world. I always question conventional wisdom. So just because someone says it's so doesn't mean it's so. They have to explain why it's so. Mark Twain has a great line. "What's an expert? Just some guy from out of town." So you know your teachers are your -- so people said "He doesn't respect authority." I -- I respect ideas and arguments --
18:37
Charlie Rose: Yes.
18:39
Larry Ellison: -- and reasoning and facts. But just because someone says, you know, this is true doesn't mean it's true. You've got to be able to explain it. So when I started -- so I would question teachers in school. I just didn't shut up and do what you're told. I wasn't very good at shutting up and doing what you're told. I think that creates problems in grammar school and high school. However, in the technology world if you can find errors in conventional wisdom, if you can -- if everyone says this is true that relational databases can never run as fast as conventional commercial databases, that's what the conventional wisdom. And I studied the papers from IBM and others and studied relational calculus and relational algebra and decided that conventional wisdom was wrong. You could build a relational database management system that ran at least as fast as the current commercial systems from IBM.
19:36
Charlie Rose: Yes.
19:38
Larry Ellison: And we went out and built it and it did run as fast and it turned out that was worth a lot of money.
19:42
Charlie Rose: Your father was a conformist. He conformed.
19:48
Larry Ellison: Yes, my father was an immigrant from Russia and was so intensely grateful that -- to be here and certainly understandable, that he thought that whatever the government said you should do because the government just knew things we didn't.
20:04
Charlie Rose: You have said before about your father that he taught me what -- what he was, is what I did not want to be.
20:10
Larry Ellison: Yes, I believe thinking -- you should think before you believe. And that believing before you think is a very -- is not a -- it might be fine for some things, you know, to do what you're told. I think in the military, I mean, that's -- you have to do that, I think, to some degree.
20:27
Charlie Rose: Yes.
20:28
Larry Ellison: So there are some institutions where you know that big drill, really drill that into you.
20:33
Charlie Rose: You can't have 100 people doing what they think.
20:35
Larry Ellison: No.
20:37
Charlie Rose: I think you said once "I've had all the disadvantages required for success."
20:40
Larry Ellison: I stole that from Tim Rice. It comes from "Evita".
20:43
Charlie Rose: Yes.
20:45
Larry Ellison: All the disadvantages you need --
20:46
Charlie Rose: Yes.
20:48
Larry Ellison: -- she had all the disadvantages that she needed to succeed. I love Tim Rice, I think he's brilliant.
20:53
Charlie Rose: Yes.
20:55
Larry Ellison: But yes, no, I have another line "If it doesn't kill you, it makes you stronger." So I think I was told so often I wouldn't amount to anything that I was very determined to --
21:03
Charlie Rose: Amount to something.
21:06
Larry Ellison: -- to amount to something. Yes exactly even you know -- I'm going to die trying.
21:11
Charlie Rose: When -- when -- have you mellowed at all? Some say you have.
21:15
Larry Ellison: Yes, yes.
21:17
Charlie Rose: Some say he's not as angry, he's not as you know --
21:21
Larry Ellison: Yes, and I think -- I think that's right. I don't think my view -- I think the rough edges have come off. So I joke about it, you know, my nature much more and I take myself a lot less seriously. And again, I'm not angry. But I think I'm as competitive as I ever was. I think it's just a -- you know, a nice -- a certain -- a certain veneer of charm in front of the same intensity.
21:47
Charlie Rose: A veneer of charm is hard?
21:50
Larry Ellison: A veneer of charm took a long time.
21:53
Charlie Rose: You believe the Cloud is -- what do you believe, is the question?
22:00
Larry Ellison: Well, I've -- I was very critical of the term "Cloud" when it first showed up and Marc Benioff applied it at salesforce.com because suddenly something he had been doing for ten years and Net Suite had been doing for 11 years was brand new. Now I think I was like how can this be? In fact, the first modern Cloud company was invented by guess who? Me? Net Suite was the first modern Cloud company. It was the year before salesforce.com. But we didn't call it Cloud, we called it Software as a Service and Mark called it Software as a Service. And then later on about ten years later, five years ago, let's say, five years ago this new term, this new thing came out and -- called the -- Amazon Elastic Cloud, EC2.
22:45
Charlie Rose: Right.
22:48
Larry Ellison: Amazon Elastic Compute Cloud. And the word Cloud is just a cool term. And all of a sudden this very charismatic term "Cloud" which is applied to Amazon, Marc said "Ah-ha. Us, too; we're also Clouds." And then Net Suite said you know "We're Cloud." And now everyone is kind of -- there are all these born-again Cloud companies.
23:11
Charlie Rose: It's a big element of the future?
23:14
Larry Ellison: There's no doubt that, you know, the business model of rather than you buying a computer and you buying software instead you rent -- you rent -- you buy a service on the Internet is kind of a utility model of computing. That's how you buy electricity. You don't have your own generator. You don't put gas into a gasoline engine and then generate your own electricity in your house. You just plug into a network. It's a utility model and you get a monthly bill. So Cloud computing is really using the Internet to deliver services as a utility model and suddenly basically computing is adopting the same model as all other networks. So we buy water from the water utility and we pay based on how much we use. We buy electricity from electricity utility, we pay based on how much we use. And now there's this extraordinary new idea called the "Cloud". What if you buy computing and output software and hardware and you pay based on how much you use. It's really utility -- it's basically the same -- it's really computing catching up to the same exact model as every other network. But everyone said "Oh, my God, it's the Cloud", which is fine great, you want to use that term for utility computing and that's fantastic I'm all for it. If that's what you insist on doing. But to claim it's this incredibly new thing and you're either Cloud or not Cloud, it's -- it was the hype around it just drove me crazy.
24:46
Charlie Rose: What have you missed, tell me? Did you miss -- could you have been a bigger force in other aspects if you had spoken beyond and focused on things beyond the obvious growth of Oracle?
25:00
Larry Ellison: Well, I think -- I know people have said "God, Larry Ellison missed the Cloud."
25:06
Charlie Rose: Exactly but you didn't.
25:09
Larry Ellison: I can pretty persuasively tell you that I invented the Cloud. I invented the network computer. Steve Jobs made it popular so the network computers you know this simple -- simple device. Well, at least I popularize the idea. We never came up with a good product. But certainly the first modern Cloud company I started and it's called Net Suite. Oracle started moving all of its applications to the Cloud over eight years ago and this is a project called "Fusion Applications". So not only did -- did we not miss the Cloud, you know, ever since the Internet became ubiquitous --
25:45
Charlie Rose: Right.
25:47
Larry Ellison: -- we have focused all of our technology effort on the internet and our slogan used to be "The Internet Changes Everything". And we talked about the utility model of computing for a long time. Now, because I ridiculed the use of the term "Cloud" people have jumped on to that and said you know "Gee, Larry Ellison, he's an idiot. He doesn't get it. He doesn't get the Cloud."
26:11
Charlie Rose: Right. When they talk now, they talk about the big race out here is between the four horsemen, they say: Google, Amazon, Apple, Facebook. Do you think that's accurate?
26:26
Larry Ellison: Well, these are all consumer-oriented companies. So we're thrilled to not be in any of those businesses. So we don't compete with any of those guys. So the consumer -- you know the consumer guys sell Web services -- you know Google maps, they sell cool devices.
26:44
Charlie Rose: iPhones.
26:46
Larry Ellison: iPhones -- by the way, I would say much bigger in devices, you left out I think the most formidable of all companies is the one you left out is Samsung. Samsung is an extraordinary company and to be reckoned with.
27:03
Charlie Rose: Clearly to be reckoned with when you look at the record and the amount of revenue that they're churning.
27:07
Larry Ellison: It's maybe the number one technology company in the world.
27:11
Charlie Rose: Do you admire them for their tactics?
27:14
Larry Ellison: These guys?
27:16
Charlie Rose: Yes.
27:18
Larry Ellison: Well, Google took the job of programming language and put it into -- and put it into the Android phone.
27:25
Charlie Rose: Right.
27:28
Larry Ellison: They cloned -- basically they cloned it which we think -- which we sued them for. And the jury actually found they did infringe on our copyrights and the judge said that that doesn't matter because you're not allowed to copyright that stuff. And now it's going up to appeal. So no, I think what Google did was unethical and actually dangerous to take our intellectual property Java and make a copy of it and put in the their phone.
27:51
Charlie Rose: Has anything Samsung done been unethical in your judgment?
27:55
Larry Ellison: No.
27:56
Charlie Rose: No. So they're a good citizen?
28:00
Larry Ellison: I think most of the guys -- the only people I have trouble with are the Google guys.
28:03
Charlie Rose: Really? Larry and Sergei you have trouble with?
28:06
Larry Ellison: I -- Larry specifically. I think --
28:10
Charlie Rose: Larry per se?
28:11
Larry Ellison: Yes, Larry per se.
28:13
Charlie Rose: Why?
28:15
Larry Ellison: Because he makes the decisions over there. He runs that company. No one else runs that company. And they decided -- let me be very clear -- when you program, when you write a program for the Android phone, you write it, you use the Oracle tools -- Oracle Java tools for everything.
28:30
Charlie Rose: So you think they're evil?
28:32
Larry Ellison: I think what they did was absolutely --
28:34
Charlie Rose: And you blame Larry Page.
28:36
Larry Ellison: 100 percent Larry Page.
28:38
Charlie Rose: So what they did is evil that makes Larry Page evil?
28:42
Larry Ellison: No, it makes what he did evil which is quite different. And I know his slogan is "Don't be evil."
28:47
Charlie Rose: Exactly. That's what I'm talking about.
28:50
Larry Ellison: And I think he slipped up this one time. But the --
28:53
Charlie Rose: So he's a good guy except this one time when he --
28:56
Larry Ellison: I -- this really bothers me. I don't see how he thinks you can just copy someone else's stuff. It really bothers me.
29:04
Charlie Rose: Let's talk about Steve Jobs.
29:06
Larry Ellison: Yes, my best friend for 25 years.
29:08
Charlie Rose: You talk about it in the book "The Billionaire and the Mechanic" and also you were there. I mean, Steve obviously knew he was dying and he knew who he wanted to speak and he thought about dying.
29:19
Larry Ellison: Yes.
29:21
Charlie Rose: Jony Ive --
29:23
Larry Ellison: Yes.
29:25
Charlie Rose: -- family spoke, and you spoke. Am I missing somebody?
29:30
Larry Ellison: No.
29:33
Charlie Rose: And what did you want to say about your friend?
29:37
Larry Ellison: Well, I wanted to -- I wanted to talk about my friendship with Steve, what it was like and a little bit about what Steve was really like because I think -- I think the biographies that have been written, they don't really capture what drove him.
29:52
Charlie Rose: Including Walter Isaacson's?
29:56
Larry Ellison: Especially Walter Isaacson. I think Walter Isaacson didn't like Steve and just had a problem admitting to his essential genius and giving him credit for doing what he did. He didn't like what Steve gave up in order to do what he did. Steve gave up -- Steve was so single-mindedly focused on Apple and building things. Building extraordinary things that he neglected other aspects of his life. But we all benefited.
30:32
Charlie Rose: Like what?
30:35
Larry Ellison: Oh, I was his best friend. He didn't have lots of friends. He didn't have an active social life -- a very active social life. He adored his family. But there was his family, his children and his wife Lorraine and then there was Apple which is the -- which was his big family. And he was completely committed to making Apple the most successful company on the planet earth.
31:04
Charlie Rose: And he did.
31:06
Larry Ellison: And he sure did. And he was interested in taking a lever and moving the world. And he did.
31:12
Charlie Rose: So tell me about it. What is it about him? We recognize the fact that he loved Apple, he wanted to make Apple great and he did. But what was it about him that enabled them to do it other than he worked hard?
31:26
Larry Ellison: He was brilliant. I mean he was our Edison. He was our Picasso. He was an incredible inventor. He could take other people's idea -- Henry Ford didn't invent the car but Henry Ford with the Model T made the first affordable car that everyone loved. And everyone -- lots of people bought. He really revolutionized the industry.
31:53
Charlie Rose: You could have it in any color you like as long as it was black.
32:00
Larry Ellison: As long as it was black. And he was obsessed with it in the same sense as Ford -- as Ford with the Model T. He was obsessive about making an mp3 player easy to use and affordable. And the first product --
32:14
Charlie Rose: Something you should have thought Sony would do.
32:18
Larry Ellison: Absolutely. You would think Sony would do it. But it was really the software component of the mp3 player that Apple -- and the beautiful design that they did. So the first iPods, you know, came not from Sony but from Apple. Steve also decided, rather brilliantly, why should I compete with Microsoft and bang my head against the wall when I can compete with Sony instead? We'd go on these long walks and he'd say who do you want to compete with? Microsoft or Sony? I'll take Sony every day of the week because I'm a software company and Sony is not. Apple is a software company. Microsoft is a software company. Sony was a hardware company. You can kill a hardware company because most, quote, hardware products like an iPod, certainly an iPhone are 95 percent software.
33:04
Charlie Rose: Yes, but Bill Gates believed the same thing. Steve had a wonderful aesthetic sense -- he was a rare person. He was a brilliant design engineer. He was obsessive about every little detail of the product. He was absolutely obsessed. I can recall Oracle did the checkout software in the Apple stores and we would go to -- he'd have the store mocked up and he and I would go in there every weekend. It drove me nuts. This is when he was developing the Apple stores.
33:36
Larry Ellison: When the Apple stores -- and everyone said stores were ridiculous, Dell was the hot company. Everyone knew you sold on the Internet, bricks and mortar was stupid. That was 20th century, this was 21st century, Steve's dead. So Steve's building stores and he wanted to make the store -- the experience in the store very, very different. The checkout experience, how you pay for things, how you bought things, how you looked at things, what the store looked like including just how you pay for stuff. And he was involved in every excruciating detail of the entire store experience. What the store looked like and how you paid for stuff. He was involved in every design detail. Jony Ive is a great designer but I'm telling you Steve edited all those --
34:16
Charlie Rose: Yes, but they were spiritual brothers.
34:19
Larry Ellison: Steve -- And Jony will tell you, Steve edited those designs and just like a good writer needs a good editor, Jony I've without Steve -- Jony Ive is locked as editor.
34:25
Charlie Rose: Yes but Steve -- I mean Steve would be the first to say -- just like you say -- he hired really great people. I mean Jony Ive being one of them.
34:35
Larry Ellison: Jony Ive is a great designer. But he can't do it without Steve. Apple --
34:40
Charlie Rose: Wait, wait, wait --
34:42
Larry Ellison: Yes.
34:44
Charlie Rose: So what happens to Apple without Steve?
34:46
Larry Ellison: Well, we already know.
34:47
Charlie Rose: What?
34:50
Larry Ellison: We saw -- we conducted the experiment and it's been done. We saw Apple with Steve Jobs, we saw Apple without Steve Jobs. We saw Apple with Steve Jobs. Now we're going to see Apple without Steve Jobs.
35:01
Charlie Rose: So you're shorting Apple?
35:03
Larry Ellison: I'm not shorting Apple. I think -- I like Tim Cook. I think there are a lot of talented people over there. But Steve is irreplaceable.
35:10
Charlie Rose: You just said to me Apple is going down without Steve Jobs. That's exactly what you said. Apple is going down without Steve Jobs.
35:17
Larry Ellison: OK, I'll say it publicly. He's irreplaceable, yes. I don't see how they can -- they will not be nearly so successful because he's gone.
35:26
Charlie Rose: Why --
35:28
Larry Ellison: You can already feel it because he made all the decisions. I mean he ran -- he ran everything. He made every single decision. I know he loved to share the credit and that's fine, but I'm telling you, he made every single decision. I was there. I watched it for 25 years. He made every -- he decided how you -- how you paid -- how you checked out of the Apple store. He decided where things were in the Apple store. He picked the colors of the original iMacs. "Sorry no beige" was his. "A thousand songs in your pocket" was his.
36:10
Charlie Rose: I hear you.
36:14
Larry Ellison: The name iPad, iTunes, iPhone were his.
36:17
Charlie Rose: Remember when you -- when he was in at Apple and then he was out at Apple and you wanted to finance him to return to Apple and he said no.
36:27
Larry Ellison: Yes. And he said "I figured out a way" -- we were at Castle Rock State Park which is just kind of -- over by the coast, about a 40-minute drive from here. And we used to go for these long walks in Castle Rock and I was telling Steve that I'd raise the money -- it cost $5 billion to buy Apple in those days. And it was run by a fellow by the name of Gil Amelio.
36:50
Charlie Rose: How much?
36:53
Larry Ellison: $5 billion.
36:55
Charlie Rose: You could have bought it?
36:57
Larry Ellison: I was going to buy it.
36:59
Charlie Rose: You had $5 billion?
37:01
Larry Ellison: I'd raise the $5 billion. I thought that -- a combination of my own cash and raising some -- dealing or borrowing. And I was going to give him 25 percent of the company and we'd take it private and Steve was going to run it. And Steve said, "You know, Larry," -- during this walk. He said, "I think I figured out a way how I can get control of Apple without you having to buy it.
37:18
Charlie Rose: Did he do that for you or for him? Because he did not want -- he wanted the independence of not having you there?
37:24
Larry Ellison: Well, not exactly. Let me be precise because I'll never forget this conversation as long as I live. I said, "OK." He said "Yes, I think I can get them to buy Next computer and I'll go on the board. And eventually I think the board will realize that I'm a better CEO than Gil Amelio and I'll become CEO." I said "OK, but Steve, if we don't buy Apple how do we make any money with you running it?" And this is when Steve turned and looked at me and he placed his left hand on my right shoulder and his right hand on my left shoulder and got very close to me and he said "Larry, this is why it's so important that I'm your friend. You don't need any more money." And I said --
38:10
Charlie Rose: Sounds like something David Geffen would say.
38:15
Larry Ellison: Well he says that to me all the time. And I started to whine. I said, "Yes, I know I don't need anymore money but why should Ned Johnson at Fidelity get it? Why shouldn't we get it? We don't have to keep it. We could give it away. We could give it to whoever we want." You know.
38:32
Charlie Rose: Yes.
38:33
Larry Ellison: "We could do really good things with this money. Let's give it all away." He said "No, no, Larry. Larry, I don't want you to buy the company." He said, "I'm not doing this for money. I think if I go back to Apple I think it's very important I have the moral high ground." "Moral high ground? That's the most expensive real estate on the face of the earth. We're not going to buy Apple? You're going to go back and you're just going to make Ned Johnson richer." For people who don't know, Ned Johnson owns Fidelity.
39:04
Charlie Rose: Exactly right.
39:06
Larry Ellison: He's the richest --
39:09
Charlie Rose: You're right.
39:10
Larry Ellison: -- in this country.
39:12
Charlie Rose: Exactly.
39:15
Larry Ellison: There's still some money on the East Coast. A little bit. I'm literally whining. I don't know how --
39:21
Charlie Rose: You're whining.
39:22
Larry Ellison: Whining -- I'm whining. And finally, we're walking, I finally start laughing, you know. It's just so ridiculous, this whole thing. What a strange life. We've come a long way since the south side of Chicago. But here are these two adopted kids from lower middle-class families kind of walking around deciding whether we should buy Apple or -- it's just crazy right. The whole thing is crazy.
39:46
Charlie Rose: Yes.
39:49
Larry Ellison: And finally I said "Steve, I'll do whatever you want me to do. And I went on the board.
39:54
Charlie Rose: Did you watch him die?
39:56
Larry Ellison: Close. Close. You mean was I there at the last --
40:01
Charlie Rose: No, no. But you watch him go through --
40:06
Larry Ellison: I saw -- you know, I'd go over there all the time and the walks -- we always go for walks. We'd always go for walks and the walks just kept getting shorter until near the end we'd kind of walk around the block or maybe four blocks, something like that and you just watched him getting weaker. And this is the strongest guy I knew. This was absolutely th strongest, most willful person I have ever met. And after seven years the cancer even wore him out. And that was what it was. He was just tired of fighting, tired of the pain. And he decided -- shocked Lorraine, shocked everybody that the medication was going to stop. He just pulled off the meds I think on a Saturday or a Sunday and by the following Wednesday he was gone.
41:02
Charlie Rose: I want to talk about a political issue here. Where do you come down on what NSA is doing?
41:09
Larry Ellison: Well, the great thing is we live a democracy. If we don't like what NSA is doing we can just get rid of the government and put in a different government. I think -- actually we've been collecting this information for so long, and long before
41:32
Nsa Was Collecting It. Let Me Tell You Who Was Collecting It: American Express, Visa, all of your credit card data we have -- all of your financial records. This whole issue of privacy is utterly fascinating to me. For example, we could do a much better job in the whole new area of privacy which is medical records.
41:51
Charlie Rose: Right.
41:54
Larry Ellison: If we could take all of our medical records and put them in a database we could then figure out what drugs worked for what people. So we take all the medical records and then we take all the genomic data about the people and we put in a database and we figure out what therapies they're getting and we figure out what therapies work, what therapies don't work because with this big database they shall all discover -- you should take Lipitor, you should take Crestor -- based on the (INAUDIBLE) -- we could do a draw dramatically better job of treating people. We'd save money, reduce suffering. Do we do that? No. Why? Everyone's scared to death about privacy. So we're not doing that. People are very concerned. So let me just set that aside. People are very concerned that the NSA is gathering all this information about people and misusing it. They're supposed to be looking for terrorists. Everyone once in a while it is true they probably hand off information to the DEA to go after a drug kingpin. They do, do that. How terrible is that? So who's ever heard of this information being misused by the government? In what way? What example in court? Who's gone to court and said "Well, I was arrested or they got me because the NSA -- the NSA somehow has misused this data."
43:20
Charlie Rose: You're saying "Whatever the NSA is doing is OK with me"?
43:24
Larry Ellison: I think it's great, you know. What is the problem with that? I mean we're finding murders, the number of assaults are down, rapes are down, crimes are being solved at a much higher rate. We're giving up privacy. Let me tell you where Americans voluntarily gave up all their privacy. They gave up all of their privacy -- I'm going to tell you how much I make. I can tell you where I bought my car. I can tell you what hotels I stay in. I'm going to tell you what airlines I ride. I can tell you how much is in my checking account, how much is in my banking account, how many overdrafts. I'll give you all that information about me in exchange for a Visa Card. America has given up essentially all of their -- not all of their privacy, not their medical records, but a huge amount of privacy in exchange of making shopping more convenient. So here are the hierarchies. I'm willing to give up huge amounts of privacy in order to get a credit card to make shopping more convenient. Well, how much privacy are you willing to give up to save a million lives through better health care? How much privacy are you willing to give up to save a million lives or a hundred thousand lives or a thousand lives by interdicting terrorism? I know of no case recently under the Obama administration, under the Bush administration, under the Clinton administration where the NSA's databases have been abused and anyone's liberties have been curtailed. I can't name a single case. Nor can "The New York Times". Now this is a funny confluence where we have libertarians in government on the Republican side of the aisle and progressives on the Democratic side of the aisle kind of coming together to protect our liberties. But I can't think of where our liberties have been infringed, I can't think of one example.
45:14
Charlie Rose: So the way the system is working is just fine with you.
45:18
Larry Ellison: I wish the system was working better. I wish we did a better job of catching these guys. I wish we had caught the guys in Boston and we are making the systems better and better and better. But thank God that Snowden has gone to Russia, a country known for its high standards of the rule of law and human rights. So I'm sure he's very comfortable with his --
45:47
Charlie Rose: Do you think he damaged our national security by what he did?
45:52
Larry Ellison: I think -- no. I think --
45:56
Charlie Rose: Do you think he's a traitor?
45:58
Larry Ellison: I think let's talk about Bradley Manning. All those WikiLeaks exposed the names of dissidents in countries where it was very dangerous to be a dissident. So willy-nilly, you know, Julian Assange and Bradley Manning as a pair caused a lot of people just to disappear, a lot of dissidents to disappear from the streets by releasing their names. Did it hurt our -- so people willing to cooperate with the United States, if our stuff gets published like this, people willing to cooperate with us in the -- dissidents in Iran, dissidents in Ecuador, you name it -- people who cooperate with us will think twice before they work with us as they think that their names are going to suddenly show up on the Internet because this data comes out. It makes this much harder for us to -
46:48
Charlie Rose: At what point would it be alarming for you in terms of government surveillance? At what point would your red line be crossed?
46:57
Larry Ellison: If the government used it to do political targeting. If the Democrats used it to go after Republicans. If the Republicans used it to go after Democrats. In other words, if it became a -- if we stopped looking for terrorists and we started looking for people with -- on the other side of the aisle. So the second the Republicans use this information to pursue their political enemies, that's a huge problem. But I know of no case of that. Democrats using this information to pursue --
47:28
Charlie Rose: That raises the other question. The Chinese are hacking us like crazy. Yes?
47:34
Larry Ellison: Yes, they are.
47:36
Charlie Rose: Probably the Red Army?
47:38
Larry Ellison: PLA yes.
47:39
Charlie Rose: PLA.
47:41
Larry Ellison: Yes. No question.
47:42
Charlie Rose: And the government knows, that, obviously.
47:44
Larry Ellison: Yes.
47:45
Charlie Rose: Some private and they know that, too.
47:47
Larry Ellison: Yes.
47:48
Charlie Rose: The object is both private company as well as the Pentagon.
47:55
Larry Ellison: Absolutely. So there's no doubt that my -- that Cisco had a lot of its secrets stolen so there's a lot of industrial espionage. By the way, it happened in France. I remember when I used to travel to France, the French Intelligence Services would search --
48:10
Charlie Rose: Bug the hotel room.
48:12
Larry Ellison: Bug the hotel room, take my computers, do all of this stuff -- I'm going to get in trouble in France. I've offended -- that we do business with -- in this one interview but I don't think it happens anymore in fact but it used to. When I used to go to France they would search everything. A lot of the intelligence services have been enlisted to do industrial espionage. I guess it's kind of -- no conventional words, just business words.
48:35
Charlie Rose: You seem like a man who has a good time with life.
48:39
Larry Ellison: This isn't practice.
48:40
Charlie Rose: You also -- I mean one of your original partners, Robert Minor, died at age 52.
48:46
Larry Ellison: Right.
48:48
Charlie Rose: Cancer?
48:50
Larry Ellison: Yes. Mesothelioma.
48:54
Charlie Rose: Did that have an impact on you?
48:56
Larry Ellison: It did. Well, my mother died of cancer. A lot of my family have died of cancer, a lot of my friends is have died of cancer. It particularly bothered me with Bob because Bob was so slow to get proper medical care so he chose not to seek specialists and that really bothered me.
49:20
Charlie Rose: Some say Steve did the same thing.
49:23
Larry Ellison: Steve ran his own therapy to a large degree. When you're a control freak, you're a control freak.
49:31
Charlie Rose: Is this assumption that you are in search of the -- you'll fund every research project you can find that's meritorious that will help us understand aging and help us live a longer fuller life. Is that true?
49:50
Larry Ellison: No.
49:52
Charlie Rose: Is it a myth, then --
49:55
Larry Ellison: Yes. I mean I have a medical --
50:01
Charlie Rose: -- a myth that Larry Ellison is obsessed by the fountain of youth and somehow he'll pay any amount of money to find the keys to immortality?
50:09
Larry Ellison: You can know exactly how much I spend. I have a medical foundation that spends money on diseases of age so I do a lot of investigations on diseases -- cancer, for example. It's a disease --
50:20
Charlie Rose: Degenerative diseases.
50:22
Larry Ellison: Yes. All that and so we don't --
50:25
Charlie Rose: Diabetes is a degenerative disease.
50:26
Larry Ellison: Absolutely.
50:27
Charlie Rose: Heart disease.
50:29
Larry Ellison: Exactly. There are lots of them. So we're clearly more vulnerable to different diseases as we get older. and it's amazing how little we know about the fundamental mechanisms of aging. So I have a medical foundation that does fundamental research on whether this mechanism -- (INAUDIBLE) years getting shorter and all that.
50:43
Charlie Rose: It has something to do within the cell structure, doesn't it?
50:48
Larry Ellison: Partially. We think it's mitochondrial -- they could damage -- there are a whole bunch of -- aging, it turns out, is a very complicated thing.
50:58
Charlie Rose: Are we understanding more and are we finding more about it and if we are what result will it lead to?
51:04
Larry Ellison: Well, I think it will lead to therapies for specific kinds of diseases. I doubt if we're going to be turning the clock back any time soon. That would be a great science fiction novel, though. Can you imagine if people stopped dying? But, you know, in the foreseeable future, certainly -- the bad news is it's not going to help you or I, Charlie.
51:25
Charlie Rose: I don't think so.
51:28
Larry Ellison: Maybe at some point we'll figure this out to the point where we can actually reverse aging. But that's many, many -- you know, that's a few generations away. But what we can do and what we have done is started a lot of that research and we have made useful progress and better understanding of a lot of these diseases.
51:45
Charlie Rose: We haven't focused much on Oracle. Oracle is doing OK?
51:49
Larry Ellison: I think Oracle is doing great. I think Oracle is doing very well.
51:56
Charlie Rose: You have a great successor over there? You seem not to be able to develop a successor.
52:01
Larry Ellison: I think there are a lot of people that can run Oracle.
52:05
Charlie Rose: Yes. But do you have a designated successor. Well, I think Safra Catz could do it. I think Mark Hurd could do it. You have just said to me that Steve Jobs was such a genius and so driven and so talented that he was irreplaceable and that when that company lost him it lost part of its future.
52:23
Larry Ellison: Yes.
52:26
Charlie Rose: Is that true with Larry Ellison?
52:28
Larry Ellison: I think we're a very different kind of company than Apple. Our stock has a much longer life cycle than Apple. The problem with consumer products, again, these are the consumer companies, you're a little bit like a rock band. OK, this cool telephone and then, you know, six months later someone had a cooler telephone and everyone starts buying that. Someone has a better movie. Our database has been around now for 25 years and has become the standard for 25 years in more and more of the world as information is going to into our database. So it's a -- so the technology cycle -- very, very fast for telephones. The technology cycle for, if you will, the back office --
53:04
Charlie Rose: Right.
53:06
Larry Ellison: -- very much slower. So I think the dynamics are different. I also think we have a wealth of talent, maybe a couple of engineers, I think, specifically one of the engineers could run the company. Safra could run the company. Mark Hurd as I said. I think we have three able people that could take over from what I'm doing.
53:28
Charlie Rose: Thank you for doing this. Pleasure to see you again in such extraordinary surroundings.
53:32
Larry Ellison: Great to see you.